The Five Guys milkshake is one of the most popular raves that has a well-known creamy texture and delicious flavor combined with the ability to mix in different ingredients. Although the original recipe is still saved, one can make a copycat Five Guys milkshake at home using a few ingredients. This guide summarises what makes these milkshakes too hard to resist and how to DIY and how to make it as close to the real thing as possible. Regardless of whether you can’t live without the classic vanilla or just need to throw some bacon or peanut butter in the mix, this copycat version has all the over-the-top hedonism that you crave, with none of the drive-thru.

The Factors that Make Copycat Five Guys Milkshakes Ideal?
The attraction of the Five Guys milkshakes is their high-quality contents, smooth consistency, and variety of mix-ins. These shakes are made of the best vanilla ice cream and the real milk that is blended to give a rich and velvety texture not too thick and not too watery. What makes them different are the various optional mix-ins such as Oreo cookies, peanut butter, salted caramel, strawberries, bananas, or even crispy bacon – so that customers could customize the shake. The balance of the flavor, creaminess, and ability to customize makes the Five Guys milkshake a great one among Fast-food shakes.
Copycat Five Guys Milkshake Recipe
Making the Five Guys milkshake at home doesn’t seem to be as complicated as you would expect. All you need with a few simple ingredients and a blender is the ability to make a mouth-watering milkshake that looks just like the real thing.
Basic Vanilla Milkshake Recipe:
Ingredients:
- 2 cups premium vanilla ice cream
- ½- ¾ cup whole milk (according to thickness)
- 1 tsp vanilla extract
- Optional: whipped cream for topping. If you are coffee lover you can also explore whipped mocha coffee recipes.
Instructions:

- Put vanilla ice cream, milk and vanilla extract in a blender.
- Blend at high speed until smooth and creamy.
- Pour in a cold glass with a scoop of whipped cream on top if desired.
- To really get the Five Guys experience, add your favorite mix ins – such as crushed Oreos, peanut butter, chocolate syrup, or strawberries and then blend.
Copycat Five Guys Milkshake Ingredients
Here’s the rundown of the most important ingredients that you will need to make a home-made Five Guys style milkshake:

- Vanilla Ice Cream: A high-quality, full-fat ice-cream is good for the creamiest texture.
- Whole Milk: Makes the shake the perfect consistency without overwatering.
- Vanilla Extract: Adds to the shake basic flavor.
- Mix-Ins (optional but iconic):
- Crushed Oreos
- Peanut butter
- Strawberries or bananas
- Chocolate or caramel syrup
- Bacon bits (for the adventurous)
Depend on your preference, add 1-2 tablespoons of your favorite mix-in to your shake before blending.
What Is the Recipe for Being a Woman in Your Own Home?
Preparing a Five Guys-style milkshake at home is a piece of cake and will not take longer than 5 minutes. First, get your vanilla ice cream and place it into a blender. Add in whole milk and a splash of vanilla extract. Then throw-in any mix-ins you want, Oreos, peanut butter and strawberries, and puree until smooth. If you prefer thicker shake, use less milk; for a thing consistency add a little more. Blend them up, and then pour into a tall glass and serve with a straw and whipped cream if preferred. Serve with one of your homemade burger or fries to make it a complete Five Guys experience.

Frequently Asked Questions
FAQ 1: The Five Guys Milkshake Mix-In is what.
Five Guys gives room to the customers for customization of milk shake using a range of real ingredient mix-ins. Some of the mix-ins that are used in these Smoothee Shakes are crushed Oreos, peanut butter, bananas, strawberries, salted caramel, chocolate syrup and even bacon. The ingredients are blended directly into milk shake base to produce even distribution of flavours all through the drink. The thing that defines their mix-ins from the rest is their use of all-natural, fresh ingredients instead of artificial syrups or powders. If you decide to make a copycat version at home, opt for the same mix-ins and mix those together with your base to give you that real mouth feel.
Q: Is it possible for me to cook a non-dairy milkshake of Five Guys?
A: Yes! Substitute whole milk with oat milk or almond milk, instead; also use dairy-free vanilla ice-cream (coconut milk or almond milk based). If you are using a high-fat dairy-free ice cream, the texture will not change, and it will still be creamy.
Q: In what thickness should a milkshake be?
A: A decent milkshake should only be thick enough to require the use of a straw but smooth enough to be drinkable without a spoon. Play around with the amount of milk relative to ice-cream depending on your liking.
Conclusion
A home-made recreation of Five Guys milkshake is the ideal way of indulging in a sweet treat of choice whenever you feel like it. Using basic ingredients, a blender, and whatever fun mix-ins you’d like, you can make your own copycat Five Guys milkshakes. If you choose to stay with the original vanilla or you want to be a little more adventurous and try new flavors such as bacon, peanut butter, and the like, this home made version is sure to satisfy you. Give it a test-run today – perhaps you’ll cut out the next drive-thru?